BY ANDY TAYLOR
Montgomery County Chronicle
CHERRYVALE — USD 447 Board of Education members Tuesday gave their blessing — albeit on a narrow 4-3 vote — to allow Cherryvale Middle-High School to be featured on “The Principal’s Office,” a reality television program that airs on the truTV cable network.
The program follows school principals in their duty to issue discipline to students. According to the TV program’s website, “The Principal’s Office” is geared toward showing the humorous or lighter side of principals’ daily handling of student matters.
Earlier in September, the majority of the school board was unable to support a motion that would have allowed the school to be featured on the reality TV program. However, the board left open the possibility of pursuing the issue again with more information provided to them from school principals George Owens and Scott Lambdin.
At Tuesday’s special meeting, Lambdin presented an information sheet detailing information and comments he had solicited from school principals who had been featured on the program last season. The overall response Lambdin received from those principals was highly favorable for the TV program, with all principals saying they would pursue it again if asked.
Those principals told Lambdin that Leftfield Productions allows school principals to have “veto power” on any subject that is deemed sensitive, controversial or too personal to a specific student matter. Once a principal tells the camera crews to stop filming a specific segment in the principal’s office, the crew must leave.
Lambdin also said several principals commented how the camera crews on their own volition stopped production of a segment because of issues they believed were too confidential or sensitive for their audience.
Lambdin did say that Leftfield Productions would be on site at the middle-high school for a period of one to two weeks — enough time for the producers to capture the daily life of principals in a middle-high school setting in rural Kansas.
Students who are featured in segments of the reality TV show will have to sign waivers (their parents also will have to affix their signatures on the waivers) that would release the school district from any potential liability.
However, school district attorney Tim Emert of Independence, who was present at Tuesday’s meeting, said he had concerns about the program, regardless if a student signs or does not sign a waiver.
“From a personal standpoint, if I were on the school board, I would not pursue it,” Emert said of the reality TV project.
“I weigh everything in terms of what am I getting and what I am giving,” Emert continued. “I have a hard time believing that the Cherryvale school district is going to gain anything from this. From a legal aspect, I can tell you that if anybody has a problem with what will been shown on this program, they will sue you guys (the school board) and this company (Leftfield Productions). It isn’t worth it.”
School board president Lance Carter said he was against the project based upon the advice from Emert. Carter said that prior to Tuesday’s meeting, he consulted Jeff Chubb, an Independence attorney who is a member of the Independence School Board and represents the Elk Valley School District as legal counsel, and Pat Baker, chief litigator for the Kansas Association of School Boards (Chubb also is a co-partner with Emert in their Independence-based law firm). Both attorneys issued the same concerns as Emert’s: that USD 447 would be opening itself to a potential lawsuit by allowing students and principals to discuss personal discipline issues on air.
“My issue here is liability and legal wise,” said Carter. “You have three attorneys who have said they would not pursue this project. Mr. Emert’s job is to protect the school district. This board member is not going to go on the opposite side of three attorneys.
“Why on earth would you have a camera in the principal’s office when discipline is being doled out?” Carter asked.
Board member Tina Cunningham said she understood why attorneys would tend to shy away from such a project.
“This is something very new to schools, and it’s something a lot of people are scared to death of,” she said. “Most people are wanting to run away from it. But, I have faith in our principal and vice principal to know that they would not put themselves, the students or the school district in a situation that would be careless. If we had a different administration and we didn’t have faith in them, then, yes, my attitude would be different.”
Lambdin said he was in total support of the project, knowing that he would use strong and careful judgment in knowing when discipline issues cross the line from humorous to serious.
And, principal George Owens said that he, too, favored the project.
“I don’t think we would do anything that would put us in a litigious situation,” said Owens.
Cherryvale Middle-High School was nominated for the program by senior Austin Smith. Smith, who was present at Tuesday’s meeting, said he thought the programs featuring Cherryvale’s principal would dispel myths about most principals.
“A lot of kids in other schools say that their principals are the meanest people on earth, but you won’t hear that in Cherryvale,” said Smith. “I nominated Cherryvale because we have principals here who treat us like human beings. Our principals listen to both sides . . . and they often provide advice, counsel and guidance. I think that would be a really good thing to show.”
While board member Sharon Wadman said she appreciated Smith’s nomination, she also said she had concerns about what she would believe to be “negativity” surrounding the program and its image of Cherryvale.
“I would rather see us on a show that puts us in a positive light,” she said. “I would rather see cameras in the classroom showing teachers providing excellent education. There are more positive things to show rather than negative.”
In the end, board members voted 4-3 to accept the program with attorney Tim Emert and superintendent Randy Wagoner to hammer out the details of the contract with Leftfield Productions. Voting in favor of the program were board members Tina Cunningham, Michelle Loganbill, Cody Smith and Bruce Thornton. Voting against the measure were board members Lance Carter, Sharon Wadman and Gina Booe.